COVID-19 Notice: Our technicians are equipped with masks and gloves complying with health and safety regulations.

Toyota Key Replacement Options: OEM vs. Aftermarket Products


Many Toyota owners fear losing their keys or having to deal with a broken one. However, the trouble does not end with these potential issues. Picking the best Toyota key replacement option can be just as hard. There are more choices than ever before, so Sherlock’s Locksmith wants to make it easier for you to choose by comparing OEM and aftermarket replacements. This in-depth guide will go over the pros and cons of each so you can make a smart decision that will protect your vehicle and make it work better.

The Importance of Knowledge in Toyota Key Replacement

Have you ever found yourself needing a Toyota key replacement, especially after misplacing or losing your Toyota key? It is not just about finding a quick fix but ensuring that the heart of your Toyota’s advanced technologies—like keyless entry and push-to-start functions—continues to beat strongly. Why? Because the key you choose plays a pivotal role in your vehicle’s functionality, security, and performance. So, how can you make sure you are making the right choice that upholds the integrity and reliability of your Toyota?

Being well-informed about your Toyota key replacement options is more than just a smart move; it is a necessity. With the right knowledge, you can sidestep the pitfalls of overpriced replacements or the trap of inferior aftermarket products. So, when faced with the challenge of a lost Toyota key, ask yourself: are you prepared to make a choice that not only gets you back on the road but does so without compromising on quality and security? Let us explore how being in the know can save you time and money and ensure your Toyota stays the dependable companion it was.

Difference Between OEM and Aftermarket Key Replacements

It is important to be clear about the difference between Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEM) and aftermarket products before getting into the details. Toyota, the OEM of your car, designs and makes OEM keys. These replacement keys are the same ones that came with your car when you bought it. On the other hand, aftermarket keys are those third-party companies that are not affiliated with Toyota. They can work like OEM keys, but they may look different, made of different materials, or not work the same way.

OEM and aftermarket Toyota key replacement products

Why Should You Get an OEM Toyota Key Replacement?


Perfect Fit, Every Time

With OEM keys made with your car’s unique needs in mind, you are getting the perfect fit every time. Thus, these tailored keys will work with your Toyota car’s intricate lock and start systems 100% of the time.

Keep the Car’s Value Up

Just as a well-kept vintage wine holds its allure over time, so does your vehicle with OEM parts. Using OEM keys can help keep the worth of your car as time passes. For the resale-savvy, sticking to original parts, like keys, can really bump up its value. It is a simple truth: cars kept in their most authentic condition often fetch a higher price. 

Reliability and Quality You Can Trust

Toyota sets high standards for testing and quality control on OEM keys. Each one goes through a lot of tests to make sure it works well. Because of this, Toyota key replacement is very reliable and lasts a long time, which aftermarket keys cannot do.

Full Warranty and Support

Going for an OEM key? No need to worry. When you buy one, Toyota will usually back it up with a guarantee and help. If the key breaks during the warranty period, the company will usually pay for it. Is that not comforting to know?


The Price Tag

Let us talk about the cost of Toyota car key replacement. Since OEM keys are the real deal, they can be pretty pricey. The price can be a fair bit steeper compared to what you would pay for aftermarket options. Hence, it might take you to pause for a moment and consider your budget.

Availability and Waiting Time

Not all Toyota keys are ready to go on a shelf. At times, you might even need to place a special order from the dealer, which could mean longer wait times. It depends on the type and age of your car, so getting one is another challenge. 

Why Consider Aftermarket Replacements?


Easy on the Budget

Most of the time, aftermarket keys are less expensive than OEM keys. These keys offer basic features at a fraction of the cost. If you are on a tight budget or want to save money, aftermarkets are a good choice. 

Available When You Need Them

Are you in a rush to get a new key? You can easily find aftermarket keys and buy them from many stores and locksmiths, such as Sherlock’s Locksmith. Because of this, they are a good choice for quick repairs or a key lockout service.

Packed with Extra Features

Some aftermarket keys have extra features that OEM keys do not have, like a longer range for remote functions or extra buttons for extra features.

A locksmith holding different Toyota key replacement options for the Yaris model


Inconsistent Quality

The quality of aftermarket keys can be a hit or miss, depending on who makes them. Some are almost as good as the originals, while others might let you down by not lasting as long or working as well.

Possible Compatibility Issues

Even though they are meant to work with Toyota cars, some alternative keys might not be compatible. That could cause issues and cost you more money later on.

Could Mess With Your Warranty

If you use aftermarket keys, some parts of your car’s guarantee might not apply anymore. Before you buy an aftermarket replacement, make sure that it does not void your guarantee.

Choosing Between OEM and Aftermarket: Which Way to Go?

Value vs. Cost

Compare the long-term value of OEM keys to the money you will save by using aftermarket keys. Sometimes, paying more upfront can keep you from having car key issues and end up having to pay more in the future.

Warranty for Your Car

Always look at the terms of the warranty for your car. It might be best to get an OEM key for your Toyota key fob while it is still under warranty to avoid any problems.

Safety Features

These days, Toyota keys have extra protection features built in. No matter if you choose an OEM or aftermarket replacement, make sure it has the same amount of security to keep thieves out.

Talk to a Local Locksmith

If you are not sure what to do, talk to a trained locksmith Pittsburgh or your Toyota dealer. Professionals like those at Sherlock’s Locksmith can give you useful advice and tips based on your unique situation.

Locksmith Near Me

Lost or broken your Toyota key and not sure what to do? Do not worry! With a little knowledge about OEM and aftermarket key replacements, you can pick the option that is best for your needs, budget, and style. Whether you are leaning towards the reliability of a Toyota key replacement or the savings an aftermarket key offers, remember it is all about keeping your car safe and sound.

At Sherlock’s Locksmith, we are experts in car locksmith services. We are here to give you advice, offer you top choices, and help you figure out how to replace your Toyota key. So, contact us and make the right choice to keep your Toyota safe, secure, and ready for the road ahead.